2020 Hall-of-Merit Ballot

Create Your Customized Hall of Merit Ballot
Article Discussing Weighting Choices

Hall of Merit Ballot

Choose Weights

pWins vs. eWins

Positional Average (Weighted Avg of Options): 0.500 (1-Year) (9-Year) (Long-Run)

Positional Averages for Pitchers (Wgted Avg of Options): 0.500 vs. Different Values for Starting vs. Relief Pitchers: (Empirical) (Based on Pitchers who Do Both)

Wins vs. Wins over Average vs. Repl. Level vs. Star

Zero out negative values (y/n): WOPA:    WORL:    WO*:

By Position: C 1B 2B 3B SS LF CF RF
DH PH PR P Off. SP RP

Weights for Postseason:   Wins    WOPA    WORL

Normalize seasons to games (enter 0 to use actual un-normalized totals)
Extrapolate missing player games? (y/n)

Discounts for World War II Seasons:
1943    1944    1945

Discounts for pre-Integration Seasons:
pre-1947    AL, 1947 - 1965;

Show top players

If a box is left blank, the value will remain the same as its previous value.

Weighted Career Leaders (1916 - 2014)

Rank	Player	Key Stat	pWins	pLosses	pWOPA	pWORL	eWins	eLosses	eWOPA	eWORL
1	Roy Oswalt	22.2	147.3	123.3	37.8	54.2	146.1	124.5	36.3	52.8
2	Jason Giambi	20.4	235.0	184.0	38.8	61.3	231.8	187.3	32.4	54.9
3	Schoolboy Rowe	19.2	143.0	117.4	33.4	49.5	141.6	118.8	31.1	47.3
4	Cliff P. Lee	19.0	134.9	116.6	27.3	43.2	134.9	116.6	27.7	43.6
5	Kevin Appier	19.0	160.6	140.3	27.2	47.0	161.3	139.6	28.4	48.2
6	Jack Clark	18.4	250.2	204.0	30.8	53.3	253.1	201.1	37.3	59.7
7	Dale Murphy	18.1	283.7	253.3	16.8	42.0	289.4	247.6	28.8	54.0
8	Toby Harrah	17.8	253.7	235.4	26.3	49.8	258.4	230.7	35.7	59.2
9	Lance Berkman	17.6	240.7	187.1	39.6	60.4	238.0	189.8	34.6	55.4
10	Orel Hershiser	17.5	193.3	177.1	31.6	53.8	192.0	178.4	30.0	52.3
11	Darryl Strawberry	17.4	219.9	163.2	46.2	64.7	213.1	170.0	32.6	51.1
12	Dwight Gooden	17.4	183.1	156.3	40.9	61.1	175.9	163.5	27.8	48.0
13	Gene Tenace	17.1	143.3	118.9	22.2	35.1	146.0	116.3	28.1	40.9
14	Hack Wilson	16.8	191.5	151.5	32.4	50.6	189.0	154.0	28.1	46.2
15	Vern Stephens	16.8	246.7	208.6	41.4	65.5	244.1	211.1	37.2	61.2
16	Andy Pettitte	16.5	210.6	175.1	46.4	71.6	206.4	179.4	38.0	63.2
17	Brandon Webb	16.3	89.3	74.0	23.7	33.6	89.6	73.7	25.2	35.1
18	Urban Shocker	16.3	125.7	98.2	31.8	46.4	120.9	103.0	23.2	37.8
19	Dizzy Dean	15.5	132.2	99.1	39.4	53.7	126.1	105.2	28.4	42.8
20	Carlos Zambrano	15.5	133.0	120.3	25.0	40.2	133.4	120.0	26.3	41.5
21	Ron Guidry	15.4	142.1	111.5	35.1	51.0	139.1	114.5	28.9	44.7
22	Indian Bob Johnson	15.3	275.1	239.2	21.2	48.5	284.7	229.6	41.2	68.4
23	Jorge Posada	15.3	172.1	146.8	34.9	50.9	168.0	150.9	27.3	43.3
24	Eric Davis	15.1	200.7	165.0	28.0	45.7	199.1	166.6	24.8	42.5
25	Curt Simmons	14.9	205.7	198.3	21.8	46.8	207.0	197.0	26.1	51.1
26	Tommy John	14.9	276.0	248.5	43.3	74.7	270.3	254.2	34.6	66.0
27	Sammy Sosa	14.8	316.6	277.5	21.4	50.5	321.0	273.1	29.9	59.1
28	Fred Lynn	14.6	245.7	217.4	23.8	45.9	247.3	215.8	27.2	49.3
29	Nomar Garciaparra	14.3	184.6	166.1	23.0	40.1	184.1	166.6	22.0	39.1
30	Camilo Pascual	14.3	185.4	185.0	14.2	37.0	189.9	180.5	24.3	47.1
31	Al Rosen	14.2	145.1	106.4	33.7	47.2	139.8	111.7	23.2	36.6
32	Javier Vazquez	14.1	177.4	174.6	16.7	38.7	181.4	170.6	25.7	47.8
33	George Foster	14.0	266.9	220.4	31.1	54.4	263.5	223.8	24.4	47.7
34	Cesar Cedeno	14.0	264.6	231.9	18.9	43.0	266.2	230.2	22.6	46.6
35	Derek Lowe	14.0	167.5	152.5	24.3	46.2	169.7	150.4	29.4	51.3
36	Fred McGriff	13.7	278.6	231.4	23.2	48.2	278.1	232.0	22.2	47.1
37	Steve Rogers	13.7	170.0	160.7	23.7	42.3	171.3	159.5	27.5	46.1
38	Larry Jackson	13.6	204.2	191.5	27.0	51.6	204.0	191.8	28.9	53.6
39	Dolph Camilli	13.6	182.3	139.4	26.7	43.8	179.3	142.4	22.1	39.2
40	Claude Passeau	13.5	163.7	148.7	23.1	43.4	165.6	146.8	28.4	48.7
41	Harry Brecheen	13.5	125.7	102.7	29.6	44.6	124.0	104.4	28.0	42.9
42	*Dolf Luque*	*13.3*	*174.9*	*159.4*	*22.6*	*44.7*	*175.9*	*158.4*	*25.3*	*47.4*
43	Kevin Mitchell	13.2	153.1	130.5	16.1	29.7	154.9	128.7	20.6	34.2
44	*Carl Mays*	*13.1*	*124.0*	*108.5*	*20.4*	*36.1*	*123.8*	*108.6*	*20.6*	*36.4*
45	Norm Cash	13.1	218.4	172.3	26.5	46.1	219.3	171.4	28.7	48.4
46	Catfish Hunter	13.0	208.9	194.0	26.5	50.4	205.2	197.7	19.6	43.5
47	Rocky Colavito	12.9	254.8	211.2	25.1	48.7	255.5	210.5	27.3	50.9
48	Lefty Gomez	12.9	163.5	141.6	29.6	48.9	155.1	150.1	15.7	35.0
49	Gil Hodges	12.8	227.2	173.0	40.6	61.7	220.4	179.8	26.7	47.9
50	Fernando Valenzuela	12.8	187.0	182.7	20.3	41.8	184.9	184.8	17.2	38.7
51	Roy Cullenbine	12.5	156.1	127.2	20.0	34.9	157.9	125.3	23.8	38.7
52	Whit Wyatt	12.5	105.7	97.1	13.7	27.3	105.8	97.1	14.4	28.0
53	Matt D. Williams	12.4	235.7	207.1	24.4	45.7	234.6	208.2	22.5	43.8
54	*Dave Bancroft*	*12.4*	*207.6*	*189.8*	*25.4*	*46.2*	*206.1*	*191.3*	*22.2*	*43.1*
55	Ernie Lombardi	12.4	161.1	149.5	18.3	35.1	164.8	145.9	25.7	42.5
56	Ron Cey	12.3	255.7	216.3	31.0	53.6	253.7	218.3	27.6	50.2
57	Chris Carpenter (1997)	12.2	136.6	124.1	23.0	39.5	135.0	125.6	21.2	37.7
58	Carlos Delgado	12.2	230.2	190.2	23.3	44.1	231.0	189.4	25.3	46.1
59	Brian S. Giles	12.1	246.1	221.4	12.8	35.5	251.0	216.6	22.5	45.2
60	Andy Messersmith	12.0	142.1	129.8	22.3	37.9	142.5	129.5	24.2	39.8
61	Albert Belle	12.0	206.3	182.9	16.1	35.7	207.2	182.0	18.5	38.0
62	Waite Hoyt	11.9	199.8	179.3	29.1	54.3	194.8	184.3	21.0	46.2
63	Jose Rijo	11.9	108.8	101.0	15.4	28.4	109.6	100.2	17.7	30.7
64	Vida Blue	11.9	199.8	184.7	25.7	48.6	194.6	189.9	16.4	39.3
65	Sam McDowell	11.9	165.4	160.4	16.5	36.2	164.9	160.8	17.5	37.3
66	Jason Schmidt	11.8	129.9	120.6	22.0	37.6	128.6	121.8	20.5	36.0
67	Dennis Martinez	11.6	228.5	217.3	23.5	51.5	225.3	220.6	17.8	45.7
68	Bob Friend	11.6	215.8	216.5	15.1	42.1	220.8	211.5	27.7	54.7
69	E. Mike Garcia	11.6	145.3	118.9	34.1	51.2	139.2	125.0	23.6	40.7
70	Josh Beckett	11.6	122.2	114.3	16.4	31.3	123.3	113.2	19.0	33.9
71	Rudy York	11.6	192.8	152.2	29.0	47.2	188.0	157.1	19.4	37.6
72	Pedro Guerrero	11.6	190.1	161.8	16.6	33.1	190.2	161.7	16.9	33.4
73	Dave Concepcion	11.6	288.2	275.0	29.3	56.3	282.7	280.5	19.4	46.4
74	Darren Daulton	11.4	109.7	97.0	14.7	24.6	110.5	96.1	16.7	26.6
75	Burt Hooton	11.3	155.2	152.4	13.9	31.9	155.6	152.0	16.8	34.8
76	Dick McAuliffe	11.3	214.7	193.8	27.8	48.1	213.4	195.2	24.9	45.3
77	David Wells	11.3	206.6	179.7	35.5	61.5	202.2	184.2	26.4	52.5
78	Jose Canseco	11.2	225.6	185.1	31.8	54.2	222.3	188.4	25.1	47.5
79	Max Bishop	11.2	163.7	131.7	32.8	48.4	159.6	135.9	24.3	40.0
80	Tony Perez	11.2	307.1	256.0	30.5	58.3	303.4	259.8	22.9	50.8
81	*Wally Schang*	*11.2*	*103.2*	*95.4*	*10.5*	*21.1*	*104.7*	*93.9*	*13.9*	*24.4*
82	John 'Boog' Powell	11.1	226.5	182.3	24.9	45.3	223.2	185.5	18.7	39.1
83	*Herb Pennock*	*11.1*	*151.7*	*129.7*	*28.3*	*46.4*	*148.4*	*133.0*	*23.1*	*41.2*
84	Brad Radke	11.1	144.2	132.7	17.5	36.0	148.3	128.6	25.8	44.3
85	Jimmy Key	11.0	152.0	128.3	28.6	47.0	149.8	130.5	23.9	42.4
86	Sal Bando	10.9	245.5	211.6	27.8	50.3	243.1	214.0	23.2	45.7
87	Bob Rush	10.9	152.1	149.5	12.2	31.4	158.2	143.4	25.6	44.7
88	Burleigh Grimes	10.9	236.3	220.2	26.2	55.5	231.7	224.7	18.4	47.7
89	Emil 'Dutch' Leonard	10.9	192.0	172.9	29.0	53.5	190.1	174.8	26.8	51.4
90	Dizzy Trout	10.8	167.5	154.4	21.9	43.3	169.3	152.5	25.9	47.4
91	Gary Peters	10.8	130.3	124.9	15.4	30.4	130.1	125.2	15.2	30.2
92	Tommy Henrich	10.8	182.1	129.2	43.9	60.4	173.5	137.8	26.1	42.6
93	Tommy Bridges	10.8	187.5	163.5	32.9	55.0	182.0	169.0	23.9	46.0
94	Roger Maris	10.7	194.9	150.8	31.0	48.5	190.9	154.8	22.6	40.2
95	Jamie Moyer	10.7	237.2	236.4	14.7	45.2	234.7	239.0	9.9	40.5
96	Eddie Joost	10.7	203.8	187.8	20.9	41.6	201.9	189.7	17.0	37.7
97	Jim Fregosi	10.5	228.5	212.3	24.1	46.1	229.6	211.2	26.2	48.2
98	Bobby Abreu	10.4	309.4	264.0	30.3	58.4	308.0	265.4	27.2	55.3
99	Harlond Clift	10.4	198.3	186.4	9.9	30.4	206.7	178.1	27.1	47.5
100	Davey Lopes	10.4	216.1	193.9	25.6	45.4	216.5	193.5	26.8	46.5

Bold = Debut before 1916
Italics = Debut before 1928

Home